According to the Congressional Budget Office’s September 2026 report, Health Insurance Options for Small Businesses, self-insured and other non-community-rated arrangements rose from 18 percent of small-group enrollment in 2014 to 46 percent in 2024, driven largely by the growth of level-funded plans.
That shift did not make headlines the way the new ACA marketplaces did during that time span. But it changed how small businesses fund health coverage, how risk pools behave, and how premiums move. For anyone operating in the health insurance market, the trend is worth understanding, because its consequences are still unfolding.
What the data actually shows
Over the decade from 2014 to 2024, small-group enrollment reorganized itself across three categories of plans.
Grandfathered and transitional plans, the pre-ACA arrangements businesses could keep, collapsed from 60 percent of enrollment in 2014 to just 4 percent in 2024. ACA community-rated plans grew early, peaking at 60 percent in 2018, then declined to 50 percent by 2024. Filling the gap, self-insured and other non-community-rated arrangements climbed from 18 percent to 46 percent.
Total enrollment in small-business health plans rose only 10 percent over the decade, from 16.9 million to 18.6 million. Meanwhile, employment at small businesses grew 21 percent from 2011 to 2024, from 29.7 million to 38.3 million. Enrollment grew at roughly half the rate of employment, which indicates coverage did not keep pace with job growth even as the mix of plan types changed.
What a level-funded plan actually is
A level-funded plan is a type of self-insured arrangement. The employer assumes financial responsibility for its employees’ health care costs, then purchases stop-loss insurance to cap its exposure. It also purchases administrative services from a third-party administrator to run the plan.
The “level” in level-funded refers to how the cost is structured. Instead of month-to-month claims variability, the employer pays a steady amount spread evenly across 12 months. For a small business, this feels much like paying a fully-insured premium: predictable, budgetable, and familiar.
The appeal goes beyond predictability. Self-insured plans are generally exempt from community rating and from the requirement to include essential health benefits. However, they must still comply with many other ACA provisions, such as covering preexisting conditions. For a small business with a relatively young or healthy workforce, a level-funded plan can cost less than a community-rated plan, because the premium can reflect the group’s own favorable risk profile rather than the broader community’s.
The risk-pool consequence
That last point is where the importance of the trend becomes apparent. When healthier groups can get a better deal outside the community-rated market, they leave it. And when they leave, they change the math for everyone who remains.
The CBO data captures this. From 2014 to 2024, average premiums in ACA community-rated small-group plans grew 46 percent, while experience-rated plans grew 35 percent. The two tracked closely through 2021, then diverged. The report attributes part of that divergence to small businesses with healthier employees moving from community-rated plans to experience-rated options with lower premiums.
Insurance has similar examples of adverse selection. When healthier groups leave a community-rated pool, the remaining pool’s risk rises. Higher average risk pushes premiums up. Higher premiums give the next tier of relatively healthy groups a reason to leave.
It is worth stating the caveat the CBO itself makes. Many factors affect premiums, and the migration of healthier groups contributes, but is not a sole cause. Premium growth also varied significantly by state, especially in states where community-rated plans made up a smaller share of enrollment.
Why this matters for the broader market
The practical result is a small-group market that has stratified into risk tiers rather than operating as a single pooled market. Healthier groups shift to self-insured and experience-rated arrangements. The community-rated market serves a population weighted toward groups that could not get a better deal elsewhere.
This has downstream effects impacting the market’s operations. Self-insured and level-funded arrangements are administratively more complex than fully-insured community-rated plans. They involve stop-loss accounting, third-party administrator relationships, and funding structures with multiple components that must be tracked, billed, and reconciled accurately. As enrollment in these arrangements approaches half the market, the administrative sophistication required to support them grows with it.
State-level variation adds another layer. Because premium growth and plan mix differ across states, insurers and administrators operating in multiple markets face a patchwork rather than a uniform national trend. What is true in a state with heavy community-rated enrollment may not hold in a state where self-insured arrangements dominate.
What to watch next
Several open questions will shape the small-group market’s next decade:
Will community-rated pools stabilize, or will the erosion continue until they serve only the highest-risk groups? The answer depends partly on how many healthy groups remain to migrate and partly on whether regulators intervene. The CBO report devotes a section to regulating the small-group market, a signal that policymakers are watching the trend.
Will the growth of level-funded plans invite new regulation? Self-insured arrangements aren’t as heavily regulated when compared to community-rated plans. If they continue absorbing market share, that regulatory deficit may attract attention.
The takeaway
The CBO data fails to show a single plan type winning. It is about a market reorganizing itself around risk. Level-funded plans grew because they let healthier small businesses opt into pricing that reflects their own risk, and that opting out reshaped the pools they left behind.
Understanding that dynamic matters for anyone who prices, administers, or supports small-group coverage. The 2024 market is structurally different from the 2014 market, even though total enrollment barely moved.
Curious how billing complexity is evolving alongside the small-group market? Explore our perspective on premium billing.
Frequently asked questions
What is a level-funded health plan?
A level-funded plan is a self-insured arrangement where the employer assumes financial responsibility for employee health care costs, purchases stop-loss insurance to limit exposure, and pays a steady monthly amount spread across 12 months. It offers the cost predictability of a fully-insured premium while allowing pricing to reflect the group’s risk profile.
How much of the small-group market is self-insured?
According to the Congressional Budget Office’s September 2026 report, self-insured and other non-community-rated arrangements grew from 18 percent of small-group enrollment in 2014 to 46 percent in 2024, driven largely by level-funded plans.
Why are small businesses moving to self-insured plans?
Self-insured and level-funded plans are generally exempt from community rating and essential health benefit requirements, so businesses with younger or healthier workforces can often pay less than they would in a community-rated plan. Level funding also spreads costs evenly across the year, reducing budget variability.
What is the difference between community-rated and experience-rated plans?
Community-rated plans set premiums based on the broader community and can vary only by age, geography, family size, and tobacco use, not by an individual group’s health history. Experience-rated plans can take a group’s own health risk into account when setting premiums, which tends to benefit healthier groups.

