Charging premiums for Medicaid expansion populations is worth it only when administrative costs remain a manageable fraction of the revenue collected. Many states have found the opposite: their administrative costs per dollar collected exceed the premium revenue itself, resulting in a net financial loss even before accounting for the policy goals it serves.
The question is not whether states should charge premiums. That decision is driven by Section 1115 waiver terms and state policy objectives around personal responsibility and coverage engagement. The question is whether the billing infrastructure can keep administrative costs low enough for the program to achieve its financial objectives.

The administrative cost problem
A Georgetown University study found that Virginia spent $1.39 for every $1 in CHIP premiums collected. This is not an isolated finding. Multiple states have encountered similar ratios in which the costs of billing, collecting, and managing delinquency for low-income populations exceed the revenue those premiums generate.
The administrative cost ratio is driven by several factors unique to Medicaid populations:
- High delinquency rates. Some states experience delinquency rates as high as 80% among premium-paying Medicaid members. Every delinquent account requires communication, follow-up, and eventual disenrollment processing.
- Low premium amounts. Medicaid premiums are typically modest ($10 to $100/month depending on the state and income level), meaning fixed billing costs represent a larger percentage of each dollar collected.
- Payment method barriers. Some Medicaid members are underbanked, making traditional ACH and check-based billing ineffective. Each alternative payment method (retail cash, money order) carries processing costs.
- Enrollment volatility. Medicaid populations churn frequently between premium and no-premium eligibility categories, creating billing system complexity and retroactive adjustment volume.
When billing infrastructure was not designed for these challenges, administrative costs increase. Manual processes, paper-based communication, and inflexible payment options all increase the cost per member while reducing collection rates.
What “worth it” looks like in practice
A Medicaid premium billing program makes sense when total billing costs remain below 10-15% of collected premiums. This threshold means the state retains at least 90 cents of every premium dollar for program funding, with administrative overhead consuming the remainder.
Achieving this ratio requires:
- Automated delinquency workflows that reduce manual intervention per delinquent account
- Electronic invoicing and payment options that lower per-transaction costs
- Payment channels accessible to underbanked populations (retail cash locations)
- Configurable grace periods and termination processes that comply with CMS requirements while minimizing administrative cycles
- Integration with state collection mechanisms (Department of Revenue, tax filing offsets) for accounts that exhaust standard collections
One state’s Medicaid premium billing program, which began in 2018 and served approximately 25,000 individuals, demonstrates that these economics are achievable. The program maintained a 17% delinquency rate, compared to rates as high as 80% in other waiver states, and kept total billing costs below 10% of collected premiums.
Why purpose-built billing changes the cost equation
General-purpose billing systems or manual processes fail in Medicaid premium billing because they were not designed for the specific challenges of this population: high delinquency, low premium amounts, limited payment access, and strict regulatory requirements.
A purpose-built Medicaid premium billing platform addresses each cost driver directly:
Electronic invoice adoption reduces mailing costs. In one state implementation, electronic invoice adoption reached 62% in the first year, with electronic payments reaching 38%. This shift cut per-transaction costs by over 50% compared to paper-based billing.
Automated delinquency collections reduce staff burden. Configurable workflows trigger notices, escalation steps, and termination processing automatically based on days-past-due thresholds. Integration with state Departments of Revenue enables income tax filing garnishment for chronically delinquent accounts without manual intervention.
Retail cash payments reach underbanked populations. Members can pay premiums at Family Dollar, Walgreens, 7-Eleven, and Walmart locations nationwide. This eliminates the payment method barrier that drives delinquency in underbanked populations.
Self-service portals reduce call center volume. Members view bills, make payments, and manage their accounts without calling the state. Every self-service interaction displaces a phone call that costs the program $5 to $15 in staff time.
Measuring whether your program is viable
States evaluating whether to implement or continue a Medicaid premium billing program should track four metrics:
- Administrative cost ratio: Total billing program costs divided by total premiums collected. Target: below 10-20%.
- Delinquency rate: Percentage of premium-owing members with past-due balances. Benchmark: achievable rates of 15-20% with purpose-built systems vs. 50-80% with manual or general-purpose approaches.
- Electronic adoption rate: Percentage of members using electronic invoicing and payment. Higher adoption directly reduces per-transaction costs.
- Collection rate per dollar spent: Net revenue after administrative costs. If this is negative, the program is costing the state money regardless of policy objectives.
States where administrative costs exceed 50% of collected revenue should evaluate whether their billing infrastructure, not the premium policy itself, is the root cause of poor economics.
Frequently asked questions
What states currently charge premiums for Medicaid expansion populations?
Several states charged premiums under Section 1115 waivers, including Montana, Indiana, Iowa, Michigan, and others. However, those have been generally disallowed for Medicaid expansion populations since 2024. Many states also have Medicaid buy-in programs for specific populations. Each state’s premium structure, income thresholds, and disenrollment rules differ based on their specific waiver terms.
Can a state reduce delinquency rates significantly by changing billing platforms?
Yes. States using purpose-built billing platforms with automated delinquency workflows, electronic payment options, and retail cash access have achieved delinquency rates of 17%, compared to 50-80% in states using manual or general-purpose approaches. The billing infrastructure directly affects collection outcomes.
What happens when a Medicaid member cannot pay their premium?
Federal regulations require states to provide notice and due process before disenrolling members for non-payment. Grace periods, hardship exemptions, and reinstatement processes vary by state waiver or program. The billing system must enforce these protections automatically while still managing the collection workflow.

